Thursday, January 21, 2010

U.S Trademark Registration Process: Avoiding A Specimen Trap


In a predictable case before the U.S. Trademark Trial and Appeal Board involving the mark DELI EXPRESS SAN LUIS, the Board held that Applicant’s applied-for mark was not a substantially exact representation of the mark as used on the packaging for the goods. Accordingly, the Board denied registration.

Applicant, E.A. Sween Company, sought registration of the mark “DELI EXPRESS SAN LUIS” (shown below) for burritos; snack cakes; and snack rolls, namely sweet rolls.


In the United States, trademark applications based upon use of a mark in commerce require the filing of a specimen of use (i.e., packaging for goods or advertising materials for services depicting the applied-for mark). The applied-for mark and mark appearing on the specimen of use must be substantially exact. Meaning consumers must perceive the applied-for mark as used on the specimen as having the same overall commercial impression. 

The examining attorney handling the application argued that the applied-for mark as shown on the packaging depicts two separate trademarks; thus two different commercial impressions. Accordingly, the examining attorney refused registration of the mark. Applicant appealed that decision.

The question on appeal was whether consumers would perceive the applied-for mark as a unitary whole or as two separate marks. In support of its case on appeal, Applicant noted that it is the owner of two registrations, one for the mark DELI EXPRESS and one for SAN LUIS. Applicant then argued that its applied-for mark is a composite of its registered marks and that, pursuant to trademark rules and regulations, it is “free to choose the elements of its composite mark that it wants to register.”

In evaluating the use of the mark on the specimen, the Board noted that a portion of the applied-for mark consisting of DELI EXPRESS appears in the top left corner of the package in a red and yellow border. The Board further noted that a portion of the applied-for mark consisting of SAN LUIS appears to the right with a green background following a stylized yellow triangle.

The Board concluded that consumers would perceive the applied-for mark as two separate marks. The Board rendered its decision based upon the following factors:

1. The term DELI EXPRESS is not only in a different font but is contained within a yellow background, and then a larger red background, separated from the remainder of the packaging design by a black bar outlining the top left corner of the package.

2. The term SAN LUIS is outside of the DELI EXPRESS border and is further separated by a fanciful triangle and placed upon a green background.

Do you perceive the mark on the packaging as a single mark? I surely don’t. In my opinion, this appeal was DOA. Given the facts of this case, wouldn’t it have been a wiser decision to simply re-file the application with an acceptable specimen then take the savings and enjoy a relaxing vacation in San Luis?

3 comments:

  1. Roger,

    There is more to this appeal than what was covered in the Board's decision, I'd encourage you to check out the following:

    (1) http://www.duetsblog.com/2010/01/articles/trademark-specimens-of-use-a-necessarily-subjective-standard/

    and

    (2) http://www.duetsblog.com/2010/01/articles/the-relevance-of-thirdparty-trademark-registrations/

    Thanks for your interest in the decision.

    Steve

    ReplyDelete
  2. Steve,

    Thank you for the additional information. It's helpful. As we attorneys that practice trademark law know, trademark law is subjective. There are likely some examiners that would have allowed the specimen. I have found during my years of practicing trademark law -- and from having been a trademark examiner myself for three years - that there are some arguments that would work with an examiner but not the Board. In my humble opinion, I think the Board got this one right -although an arguably close case.

    Roger

    ReplyDelete
  3. We reacquire a soft copy of the logo in JPEG format.The process of registering your own trademark, if your business is applicable for the same.

    Trademark Lawyer Los Angeles & filing a trademark

    ReplyDelete